diff --git a/guidelines/decision-process.md b/guidelines/decision-process.md index 8b13789179..2716b155b3 100644 --- a/guidelines/decision-process.md +++ b/guidelines/decision-process.md @@ -1 +1,21 @@ +# Decision making process + +## Definitions +1. *Consensus* is defined as lack of sustained opposition. +2. *Good standing* is a characteristic of group members who fullfill their implicit and explicit obligations and hence are allowed to excercise all of their rights within the group without restriction. +3. *Blacklist* (*blacklisted*, *blacklisting*) is a taxative enumeration of group members who are temporarily excluded from exercising their rights within the group. +4. *Normative keywords* as defined in [BCP 14](https://tools.ietf.org/html/bcp14) + +## Rules +1. Any current group member is deemed to be in good standing unless blacklisted. +2. Any group member in good standing MAY make a proposal to the group via + - raising an issue, + - PR (against the repo or wiki), or + - orally in a monthly group meeting. +3. Approval or rejection of proposed solutions and decisions SHOULD be driven by consensus. +4. Consensus MAY be reached as part of the PR or issue resolution process. +5. The monthly group meeting has the ultimate decision making authority. + - Chair Group or Chair don't have a decision making authority, see [chair-group.md](chair-group.md) and [chair-group-members.md](chair-group-members.md). +6. In case consensus cannot be found over multiple iterations of arguments and counter arguments, a monthly group meeting MAY reach consensus to mandate the Chair Group to organize a ballot among all group members in good standing. The ballot wording, options, and success criteria SHOULD be explicitely defined in a monthly meeting. The Chair Group only administers and implements the ballot and its results. +7. Blacklisting procedure is TBD by monthly meeting consensus if and when needed.