-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 662
Description
The code for S-class groups, S-units and Selmer groups of number fields, and more generally étale algebras, is not entirely satisfactory in the following respects:
-
The code for computing Selmer groups is somewhat convoluted. Conceptually, the computation of the generators for principal ideals of the form genorder belongs in selmer_group, not _S_class_group_and_units. It would be more correct to return, as S-class group generators, pairs (gen, order) instead of triples (gen, order, pr), and leave the computation of the principal ideal generators to selmer_group.
-
The docstrings are not very clear. The sentences are very long and contain awkward constructions ("a fractional ideal representative of the S-class group generator whose order (in the S-class group) is order"; "principal generator").
-
The docstring of NumberField._S_class_group_and_units suggests that to obtain a principal ideal, genorder can be multiplied by any fractional ideal J whose class is in the subgroup of the class group generated by ideals in S. However, the condition is more strict: J must be in the subgroup of the ideal group generated by ideals in S.
The attached patch does the following things:
-
Move computation of generators of principal ideals from NumberField._S_class_group_and_units to NumberField.selmer_group.
-
Add a method _S_decomposition to PolynomialQuotientRing_generic, which computes the decomposition of an étale algebra as a product of number fields. Use this function in S_class_group, S_units and selmer_group.
-
Delete PolynomialQuotientRing_generic._S_class_group_and_units, and move its code and doctests to S_class_group, class_group, S_units and units.
-
Reimplement PolynomialQuotientRing_generic.selmer_group to compute the Selmer group as the product of the Selmer groups of the distinct components, instead of imitating the algorithm of NumberField.selmer_group.
-
Make the documentation more precise.
Apply: attachment: trac_14746_doctests_32_64_bit_undo.patch, attachment: trac_14746_selmer_group_cleanup.patch, attachment: trac_14746_docstring_fixes.patch
Depends on #14489
CC: @sagetrac-ArgaezG @sagetrac-akoutsianas
Component: number fields
Keywords: S-class group, S-units, Selmer group, sd51
Author: Peter Bruin
Reviewer: John Cremona, Alejandro Argaez, Angelos Koutsianas
Merged: sage-5.12.beta2
Issue created by migration from https://trac.sagemath.org/ticket/14746